IR35 Tax Explained for UK Contractors
IR35: Navigating the Rules, Realities, and Risks
Picture a contractor named Sam. For years, Sam thrived in the UK technology sector, offering expertise through a limited company. Like many, Sam valued independence, the flexibility to choose projects, and the tax benefits of working for herself. Then IR35 arrived, changing the landscape overnight.
IR35—shorthand for the UK’s Intermediaries Legislation—was designed to address a simple but thorny problem: tax avoidance via ‘disguised employment.’ If someone acts like an employee but is paid as a business, are they paying their fair share? For Sam and thousands of others, this question isn’t theoretical—it shapes work, income, and the day-to-day reality of being a contractor.
Who IR35 Touches: The People and Businesses in the Crosshairs
IR35 isn’t just a contractor issue. It draws in:
Contractors—especially those working through limited companies (Personal Service Companies, PSCs)
Clients/End-Users—those who pay for services
Agencies/Intermediaries—entities between contractor and client
If you’re a sole trader, IR35 doesn’t technically apply, though employment status rules still matter. Umbrella company workers, who are paid via PAYE, are also usually outside IR35’s scope. But for anyone using a PSC, these rules can’t be ignored.
Inside vs. Outside IR35: Where Do You Stand?
At the heart of IR35 are two starkly different outcomes:
-
Inside IR35: You’re treated as an employee for tax purposes. That means PAYE and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) are deducted at source. The client or agency (unless they’re a small business) handles the tax admin. Your take-home pay drops—sometimes by as much as 25%—and many expenses you once claimed disappear.
-
Outside IR35: You’re seen as genuinely self-employed. You can pay yourself through dividends, claim allowable business expenses, and enjoy the full suite of tax advantages that limited company status brings.
“Inside or outside IR35? For contractors, it’s not just a tax status—it’s a fork in the road that defines your working life.”
Decoding IR35 Status: Tests, Tools, and the Human Factor
Determining IR35 status isn’t a tick-box exercise. HMRC and the courts look at:
Right of Substitution: Could you send someone else to do your work?
Control: Who decides how, when, and where you work?
Mutuality of Obligation (MOO): Is there a recurring obligation for the client to offer, and you to accept, work?
Other Clues: Who provides equipment? Are you integrated into the client’s business? Do you work for multiple clients?
Both the written contract and actual working practices are scrutinised. HMRC offers a CEST tool, but its results aren’t always definitive—real-world practices carry real weight.
Who Calls the Shots? IR35 Status Decision-Making
Public Sector (since 2017): The client decides and issues a Status Determination Statement (SDS).
Private Sector (since April 2021):
Medium/Large Businesses: Client decides, must issue SDS.
Small Businesses: The contractor’s PSC decides. (Small = two of: turnover ≤ £10.2m, balance sheet ≤ £5.1m, ≤ 50 employees)
If you disagree with an SDS, you can challenge it. The client must reply within 45 days.
The Fallout: What Happens When IR35 Applies?
If Inside IR35
PAYE and employee NICs are deducted
Employer NICs and Apprenticeship Levy may apply
You lose most expense claims
Your limited company’s tax advantages shrink
If Outside IR35
PSC is paid gross
You can claim business expenses and pay yourself flexibly
Penalties, Audits, and the Cost of Getting it Wrong
A true story: In 2023, a friend of mine received a letter from HMRC. They’d determined his contracts were inside IR35. The result? Years of back taxes, penalties, and months of stress. HMRC can look back up to six years (or 20 if they suspect deliberate evasion).
If you’re found to have misclassified or failed to take reasonable care, penalties and interest stack up, making compliance not just good practice but essential survival.
Umbrella Companies and Sole Traders: Special Cases
If you use an umbrella company, you’re technically employed and paid via PAYE—IR35 doesn’t apply. For sole traders, IR35 is irrelevant, but HMRC still checks if you’re truly self-employed.
Crunching the Numbers: IR35 and Your Income
Being caught inside IR35 can reduce take-home pay by up to 25% compared to outside. Calculators like ContractorCalculator’s IR35 Taxes Calculator can help you model the impact before you sign a contract.
What’s Changed? Recent IR35 Reforms
2021: Medium/large private sector clients became responsible for IR35 decisions.
2022: Proposed repeal was scrapped; current rules remain.
2025: Small business thresholds increased, relieving some clients of off-payroll obligations.
FAQs: IR35 Unpacked
What is IR35?
It’s tax legislation designed to stop disguised employment through intermediaries.
What does ‘inside IR35’ mean?
You’re taxed as an employee; PAYE and NICs are deducted.
Who decides my IR35 status?
Your client—unless they’re a small private business, then it’s your PSC.
Can I dispute an SDS?
Yes—your client must respond within 45 days.
Does IR35 apply to umbrella workers or sole traders?
No, but employment status rules still affect sole traders.
Comparing IR35 Outcomes
| Aspect | Inside IR35 | Outside IR35 |
|---|---|---|
| Tax Treatment | PAYE, employee/employer NICs | Corporation tax, dividends |
| Expenses | Limited | Broad business expenses |
| Status Decider | Client (unless small) | PSC (if small client) |
| Take-home Pay | Lower (up to 25% less) | Higher |
| Rights | Some employment rights | No employment rights |
Best Practices: Staying Compliant and Informed
For Contractors
Review every contract for IR35 implications
Align working practices with contract terms
Maintain records of business activities (insurance, multiple clients, marketing)
Use IR35 contract review services or seek professional advice
For Clients
Build robust IR35 assessment processes
Issue detailed SDSs and keep records
Regularly audit supply chains
For Agencies
Understand your fee-payer responsibilities
Communicate openly with contractors and clients
The IR35 Impact: Facts and Figures
Tax Revenue: Initial forecasts of £220m/year in NIC and £80m in income tax have been missed by a wide margin.
Compliance Costs: Businesses with large flexible workforces, such as IT and engineering, face significant compliance costs.
Sector Impact: Sectors like the NHS have seen contractor shortages and project delays linked to IR35 changes.
IR35 in Practice: Real Queries from Real People
“Am I inside or outside IR35?”
“How do I check my IR35 status?”
“Can I use an umbrella company to avoid IR35?”
“What’s an SDS?”
“How do I advise my clients on IR35?”
These are more than search queries—they’re urgent, practical concerns that shape daily decisions for contractors and businesses alike.
Resources for Deeper Insight
IR35 at a Glance: Quick Reference Table
| Topic | Summary |
|---|---|
| Origin | Introduced 2000; Chapter 8, ITEPA 2003 |
| Applies to | Contractors via PSCs, clients, agencies |
| Not affected | Sole traders, umbrella employees |
| Status Decision | Client (public/medium-large private); PSC (small private clients) |
| Status Criteria | Substitution, control, mutuality of obligation, business risk, contract terms |
| Inside IR35 Result | PAYE tax/NICs deducted, reduced expenses, lower take-home pay |
| Outside IR35 Result | PSC paid gross, can pay dividends, claim business expenses |
| Disputes | Contractors can dispute SDS; client must respond in 45 days |
| Penalties | Interest and penalties for incorrect status or lack of reasonable care |
| Recent Changes | 2021: private sector reform; 2025: small business threshold changes |
| Tools | HMRC CEST, IR35 calculators, contract review services |
Next Steps: Navigating IR35 with Clarity
For UK contractors, the IR35 journey can be daunting. But knowledge is power. Review your contracts, understand your working relationship, and don’t hesitate to seek expert advice. If you’re a client or agency, robust processes are your best defence. IR35 isn’t going away—but with diligence and the right support, you can navigate it confidently.
“Understanding IR35 isn’t just about compliance—it’s about protecting your livelihood and shaping the future of flexible work.”
